Beer at the Church, or Monastery! Revised with List of beers in a Church!

Brother Jean, Brewer collaborator

Read to the Bottom for tips on finding beer in a church! This year I have been two seemingly unusual beer fests held on grounds of Indiana religious institutions:  Monastery Beer Fest on Sept. 16, and the Irvington Brew Fest on Sept. 23.  There were several similarities between the two, beyond the obvious. Both included a small number of brewers, both attracted many local neighbors, both included tables with ample opportunity to chat.  Suddenly, “Beer at the Church” became appealing!

Maybe this simply takes me back to one of my first New Years Eve celebrations with my wife. We were invited by friends to a party at their church. I was a little suspicious as church parties had been okay in my youth but not where I’d think of spending NYE.  But wait, this was a Catholic Church on the Indianapolis South side where the entry cost included a bottle of whiskey!  I was cautious but I learned those people were there to party.

The Monastery Brew Fest on the grounds of Monastery Immaculate Conception in Ferdinand, IN, had its first year as organized by  St. Benedict’s Brew works, also on the monastery grounds. This Monastery Brew Fest was truly unique and very enjoyable.   I’ve been with trappist monks within Belgian breweries, but I’ve not had the pleasure of consuming beer with a monk on premise in the U.S.   Don’t misunderstand.   St. Benedict’s Brew works is NOT monks brewing beer; it is a few regular guys as brewers.   Yet, two of the beers served at this fest were a collaboration with monks from the nearby Saint Meinrad Archabbey,  who are basically home brewers.  This was a rare treat to have the near equivalent of a U.S. abbey beer.

The Monastery Brew Fest likely had fewer attendees than organizers wanted, which meant virtually no lines and a very relaxed opportunity to chat with brewery people and also with those attending.   I met a veterinarian from Evansville, a nice family from Louisville, and many from Jasper or Ferdinand who stopped by. There were few, maybe no, young ‘drink all you can’ types.   It was great to see Taxman Brewing of Bargersville, Tin Man of Evansville,  Schnitz from Jasper, Carsons of Evansville, and Tell City from (oh, you know!), plus, of course, Saint Benedict’s Brew Works.    In addition to those five, several distributors had provided beer in keg and in bottles making  ample beer to try and especially Belgian Trappist beers!
St. Benedict’s Brew Works, as host, offered 6 beers:   a Belgian Dubbel, a Belgian Tripel, A Belgian Quad, a Farmhouse ale, and the collaborations with the monks:  an IPA (4.5%) and Monastic Midnight Stout (7%).  Neither of those collaborations were to be on sale regularly and were specifically brewed as abbey beers for the brewfest!  Brother Jean, a young Benedictine monk, told us he and several others had been ‘home brewing’ 5 gallon batches on a stove using that experience to help St. Benedict’s Brew Works with these 2 offerings.  The IPA was similar to a Northeast (often called New England) IPA because it was lower alcohol, delivered citrus flavor being more fruity than bitter.  This IPA contained Mosaic and Citra hops along with Centennial and Cascade. The stout had a great deal of deep roast with chocolate notes.

St. Benedict’s is the project of Vince Luecke and Andy Hedinger who were both present at this fest with the blessing, literally, of the sisters.  Vince was very helpful  getting me information in advance and acting as host for all while Andy handled the booth and general issues.  On a normal day, you follow directions to the Monastery Immaculate Conception, the home of the Sisters of St. Benedict, an imposing structure on the hill east of Ferdinand, IN,  where guided tours are offered Tuesday through Friday at 10:00 a.m., 11:00 a.m., 1:00 p.m., and 2:00 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday at 1 p.m. and 2 p.m. plus you can join them for prayers or mass. Sisters Tour Hours and info click here!  But back to the brewery!

Once on the monastery grounds  continue past the monastery to the buildings furthest away where the brewery is on the left and the gift shop for the monastery is on the right with a small garden in between just off the parking lot.  None of the beers offered at the Monastery Brew Works sampling seem to be a regular offering from St. Benedict’s and they have brewed  many styles in the 2 years they have been open.  On a typical day you may find a pale, an IPA, a hefeweizen, a kolsch, or other variety! Hours are  Thursday/Friday, 5pm-10pm; Saturday, 10am-10pm; & Sunday, 12pm-8pm.


The Irvington Brew Fest was an East side get-together on the grounds of Our Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church, an staple of the community since 1909.  The fest featured six breweries, one cidery, and a few hundred local citizens, enough that the festival had to be announced full and sold out  about 30 minutes from the start.  I had talked to the organizer, Amy Petrone, earlier to ask why this fest was different than all of the others.  The answer can be summed in a sense of community. While there were many lines to get beer, there were also people sitting and chatting.  Like the Monastery Beer Fest, there did not seem to be those intent on drinking as much as possible with a goal to get tipsy or more.  There were a variety of over-21  ages which seemed to include adult families.  It was very clear by listening to those getting their beer that many were learning about beer styles and about the breweries nearby.

There were seasonal beers from most of the 5 breweries as well as staple brews:   Saint Joseph, St. Joeberfest (a delicious Oktoberfest style Marzen) and Cornerstone Kolsch — both fitting for fest at a church!  Metazoa, Kinkajou (honey weiss) and Nap in the Hammock (cream ale); Fountain Square Cinnamon Girl (spiced ale) and Saison Du Jour; Black Acre, Oktoberfest and Saucy Intruder (a bold Rye IPA, at 7%); Bier Brewery Brewery Pumpkin Ale and flagship Weizengoot (hefeweizen); and Sun King Bitter Druid (ESB, British style) and Fistful of Hops (IPA).  Black Acre Brewery is literally 0.4 miles from the grounds in Irvington, and all of the remaining breweries are about 10 minutes away from the church and school, except Bier Brewery which is clearly east-side, and almost straight up Emerson Avenue, but might be 15 minutes by car!  This year Ash & Elm Cider, located about 7 minutes by car down Washington St, joined the Fest with a Dry cider and a spiced pumpkin cider.

ONE MAJOR difference with this fest is that attendees get not only a taster glass and also a pint glass. While they are allowed unlimited small samples, they are encouraged to buy a pint for $5 of one of their favorite beverages.   Since there are 10 beers and 2 ciders, it is rather easy to decide what you may want to drink with friends!  Participants got a small ‘swag bag’ with a passport describing the beers, and a sticker or coaster.   Proceeds after expenses from the Irvington BrewFest go to support the school on the church grounds.  Amy Petrone has been running the event since 2012.   She told us she really wants that neighborhood feel, that gathering of family and friends as it has been since the beginning.  We noted many locals going for the food from La Mexi-Gringa, which is a small tamale and taco joint about a mile further east on Washington Street.  There was also the NY Slice pizza truck!  Tables were arranged under the big tent and there were “high top” standing tables on the church lawn. A duo called Audio Diner provided music from a small stage.

St. Joseph Brewery, Indianapolis

Where to find Beer in  a Church!  

Indianapolis: St. Joseph Brewery, 540 N College Ave,   just steps from Mass. Ave. this brewery has great beer and great food in one of the prettiest brewery spaces you can visit in the city!    if you love hops go for the award winning Confessional IPA with citrus and grapefruit. If you want something closer to an abbey beer try my fav. the Benevolent Belgian Blond

(Indiana Brewers Cup Gold in 2015). The Cornerstone Kolsch rounds out the core beers as an easy drinking golden beer. Yet there are usually ten seasonal beers on tap!  $1 off pints on Tuesday, Growlers of Seasonals only $8 on Wednesday.    Alan Simons does a great job as a very experienced brewer.  He may have the prettiest nook for a brew pub in town.

Cincinnati:  Taft’s Ale House, 1429 Race St,  in the Over the Rhine District.  Equally beautiful and impressive. A friend loves the Nellie’s Keylime Caribbean Ale which does remind me of a hot day in the Florida Keys.   Last month on my visit I went for the Cherrywood, a nice amber ale but I had to get a small sample of the Tripel which gets me closer to the abbey but at 9.8% I needed to be cautious.  I had just missed the GABF Gold medal winning Vienna lager on tap.

Taft’s Ale House, Cincinnati

Louisville:  Holy Grale, 1034 Bardstown Rd.  This is not a brewery but is the first church I ever entered to drink beer and is owned by two wonderful supporters of craft beer!   if you are lucky they will  have a selection of actual Belgian beers.  I always head to the choir loft which is very cozy and opens at 6 p.m.   This has less of the grand feeling of a large church than either St. Joseph or Taft’s yet between the great beer selection, fabulous food, and cozy atmosphere on the main floor or in the loft

Greg Kitz